News:

SMF - Just Installed!

Main Menu

Recent posts

#51
I can see quite a few points actually, but none of them seem very sharp... ;D
#53
I fear to offer opinion amongst my betters on the subject!
#54
Quote from: Imperial Dave on Mar 02, 2026, 07:16 PMDiscuss...

Well, Dave, having called upon us to discuss the article, I note you have not given your opinion.
#55
Army Research / Re: Sardinians in the Second P...
Last post by lionheartrjc - Mar 04, 2026, 04:21 PM
There is mention of Mammula in Livy Book 23, but I think this comment of a double-strength legion is an invention for the scenario. Could Rome have spared a double legion for Sardinia with everything that was going on in Italy?
#57
Army Research / Re: Sardinians in the Second P...
Last post by Jim Webster - Mar 04, 2026, 10:38 AM
Steven mentioned an article to me
SPQR Scenario.
Caralis: The Battle for Sardinia, 215BC

In it there is the comment.
"Therefore, early in 217 the praetor Aulus Cornelius Mammula was sent to reinforce the island's garrison with Legion V, a full-strength double legion with some 10,000 foot and 800 horse."

I have hunted high and low for any evidence of this, the only thing AI turns up when I ask about it is this article, and I think I've scoured Polybius and Livy and found nothing.
Anybody got any hints?
#58
Battle Reports / Re: Caesarian Romans v Gauls u...
Last post by simonw - Mar 04, 2026, 08:40 AM
David, that sounds heartfelt; the voice of bitter experience. But that's life. At least in wargaming there is always tomorrow.
Cheers, Simon :)

Melior fortuna iterum.
#59
Battle Reports / Re: Caesarian Romans v Gauls u...
Last post by dwkay57 - Mar 04, 2026, 08:28 AM
So it is not just DBA where the quirks of the gods have an impact?
#60
Army Research / Re: Sardinians in the Second P...
Last post by Jim Webster - Mar 04, 2026, 05:40 AM
Cheers Steven
The article is currently with the editor  ;)